The Farmer's Daughter USA

Hi, I'm Amanda! My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm also a practicing attorney.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Work with Me
    • Speaking
    • Giveaways
    • Social Media Consulting
    • Sponsored and Guest Posts
  • Gift Shop
    • Cart
    • Checkout
  • About Me
    • Media
    • Terms of Use

Senate Introduces Bill to Stop California’s Prop 12

August 24, 2021

The closer we get to California implementing prop 12, the more people seem to be ringing the alarm bells. Those warnings finally reached Washington, DC. Senators Joni Ernst and Chuck Grassley introduced legislation to limit prop 12’s application outside of California. But will it work?

Let’s break this down.

What is California’s Prop 12?

California voters overwhelming passed the Prevention of Cruelty to Farm Animals Act in 2018. Honestly, I don’t know a lot of people–farmers included–who support farm-animal cruelty. So I’m sure an affirmative vote seemed like an easy choice.

But prop 12 isn’t about cruelty to animals; it’s meant to fundamentally change animal agriculture across the United States. It applies to veal calves, breeding pigs, and egg-laying hens, and mandates the minimum housing spaces that farmers must give these animals. That sounds nice, but it’s completely devoid of any reference to good animal husbandry. (Check out this article by Wanda of Minnesota Farm Living for some insight into sow housing.)

Hog produces are, arguably, hit the hardest by prop 12. That’s because only 4 percent of producers in the U.S. meet prop 12’s requirements for sow housing. Four. Percent. Meanwhile, California makes up 15 percent of the pork market.

Why does this matter to farmers outside of California?

I know what you’re thinking: why do farmers outside of California care about this law? If it’s a California law, it only applies to California farmers; right?

Wrong. That’s the craziest thing about prop 12 (and, quite frankly, other ballot proposals in California). Prop 12 applies to any farmers selling their product in the state. So it doesn’t matter where you raise hogs–California, Michigan, or Canada–you can’t sell them in the state unless you comply with the new law.

At least two lawsuits by agriculture groups have argued this aspect of prop 12 violates what’s known as the dormant commerce clause (I explained the concept here). Unfortunately, those arguments have fallen on deaf ears (though one lawsuit is still pending). The Supreme Court has declined to hear similar cases, meaning there’s likely no relief coming from the courts.

What would the EATS Act accomplish?

Ernst and Grassley’s bill tries to enforce the constitution’s commerce clause. According to Magnetic Ag, it says that one state can’t regulate agricultural activities in another state. So, in other words, California can only regulate California farmers; it can’t regulate Iowa farmers.

It’s an alluring concept, so long as your farm is located in the right state. It won’t do anything to help California farmers, of course (er, sorry…). And farms located in states that enjoy radical regulations (here’s looking at you, Washington and Oregon) will be at the mercy of their electorate. For obvious reason, that’s still pretty scary.

But the EATS Act would be a nice way of sticking it to those on the west coast. California has played these games before–passing ballot proposals that essentially create new requirements for growing food across the entire country. Farmers and producers have to comply because the California market is too big to lose. The EATS Act could put a stop to it.

I also believe it could slow down future ballot measures. In reality, these are proposed in California for two reasons: there’s a better chance they’ll pass and the California market is big enough to influence the whole country. If the second part of that equation is axed, there’s less incentive to fund the campaigns supporting these laws. Voters may also think twice about putting costly and unnecessary regulations on their own farmers, ultimately making them less competitive.

Will EATS become law?

Unfortunately, I don’t think there’s even a remote chance the EATS Act is ever signed into law. I don’t see much appetite for it in the Senate (its two sponsors are both Republicans), let alone the house. I imagine Senator Cory Booker would twist it into an excuse for animal abuse. And I don’t foresee many Congressman wanting to step out on a limb to support it. It may work as part of a larger farm bill, but even that would be difficult.

Perhaps in the future there would be a better political climate for the bill. If our national atmosphere is ever serious about checking California’s nationwide power, the EATS Act needs to be introduced then.

So while I support the EATS Act, I don’t see it becoming law. That means hog producers will have to make a choice: bow to California’s authority or cut out 15 percent of your potential market. I’ll continue to hope it’s the latter. Maybe then California voters will start caring a little more.

signature
Share this:
«
»

Filed Under: Animal Agriculture, Animal Care, Animal Rights Tagged With: animal agriculture, ballot proposals, California, congress, federal government, legal, legislation

Comments

  1. agridane says

    September 20, 2021 at 10:54 am

    Thanks for a very interesting article.

Hi, I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney and I'm passionate about agriculture!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Subscribe via Email

Archives

Latest on Twitter

May 1, 2023
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

Healthy Soil’s Big Impact t.co/xBO5tCKP17

  • Reply
  • Retweet 0
  • Like 2
March 29, 2023
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

The Silver Lining in This Year’s Dirty Dozen List t.co/qD3kFSYmtE

  • Reply
  • Retweet 0
  • Like 1
March 2, 2023
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

Right-to-Repair Challenges Continue t.co/sOTL8t7fPx

  • Reply
  • Retweet 3
  • Like 4

Latest on Facebook

The Farmer's Daughter

5 days ago

The Farmer's Daughter

We're done planting corn!! 🥳🥳 I haven't posted many updates about #plant23 because it's been a little rough. 🫣 But we're getting there!

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

1 week ago

The Farmer's Daughter

And...go!

... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Reducing food waste is a goal we should all have. Vilifying a product that can help us do that with disinformation isn't helping. My latest for AGDAILY

... See MoreSee Less

Social media is wrong to vilify Apeel's shelf-life technique | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

Apeel is a useful tool to safely and effectively extend the shelf life of fresh produce, yet activists aim to denigrate this remedy to food waste.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

My biggest concern is one of the honorable mentions--gobbling up productive farmland and turning it into something else. What about you? What concerns you most as a threat to agriculture?

... See MoreSee Less

The 6 biggest threats to farming on a global scale | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

As a society, we have a responsibility to understand the urgency of the “C’s” and act accordingly -- to think globally and act locally.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Last week the Supreme Court dished out a blow by upholding California's Prop 12. I break down the opinion and what it all means here:

... See MoreSee Less

Breaking down the SCOTUS opinion upholding Prop 12 | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

Given the recent SCOTUS appointments, it was hard to anticipate how it would rule on the challenge to California's Prop 12.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

Latest on Instagram

thefarmersdaughterusa

I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney by day, and "agvocate" at night.

Amanda Zaluckyj
Consumers are feeling the pinch, and so are farmer Consumers are feeling the pinch, and so are farmers. The increased costs for #plant23 stem from higher seed, fertilizer, chemical, and land costs. Farmers are also paying higher interest rates. And keep in mind that #plant22 was also more costly than pre-COVID times.

#agriculture #hardtimes #plant23 #plant2023 #sustainableag #economicsustainabilty #usagriculture #usfarms #usfarmers
I don't know who needs this today, but here's Misc I don't know who needs this today, but here's Mischa with the sadest puppy-dog eyes and adorable belly rolls. 😍😍

#Mischa #dogsofinstagram #dogs #bellyrubs
Food labeling matters. Here's why. #food #foodlab Food labeling matters. Here's why.

#food #foodlabels #foodlabelsmatter #knowyourfarmer #knowyourfood
Just in case you're not sure why I miss my straigh Just in case you're not sure why I miss my straight hair. It randomly failed to curl last week. This was the beautiful result. 😍

#cancersurvivor #chemocurls #farmersdaughterstrong #bebrave
Don't let anyone tell you that farmers (yes, even Don't let anyone tell you that farmers (yes, even conventional farmers) don't care about soil health. The truth is, farmers are *obsessed* with it.

#farming #agriculture #healthysoil #soilhealth #sustainableag #sustainableagriculture #modernagriculture #modernag
Modern planting is a lot more sophisticated than j Modern planting is a lot more sophisticated than just placing seeds in the ground. Our equipment actually allows us to control how many plants we want per acre, precisely spaces each corn seed in the rows, and controls how deep the seed is planted. It's all part of precision agriculture that employs high-tech sensors and data to improve efficiency and yields.

#farming #modernagriculture #corn #cornplanting #plant23 #plant2023 #plant #farms #sustainable #sustainableagriclture #themoreyouknow💫 #usagriculture
Perspective. Last week I was in the cancer center Perspective.

Last week I was in the cancer center for routine labs and a port flush. Unfortunately, my port wasn't working. There's al these little "tricks" the nurse tries to open it up. One of those was putting different pressure on it. Needless to say, it hurt! And it didn't work. So she had to get something called TPA, put it in the line, and let it work--something that takes at least a half hour.

So there I sat for half an hour. In pain. A bit nauseous. And missing a work meeting. As you can imagine, I wasn't super happy about any of it.

But then came a voice over the hospital's intercom system (something that NEVER happens). There was a Code Blue in the neo-natal center. I asked my nurse what that meant. She said a baby was born without breathing. The doctors would do everything they could to resuscitate, and the Code Blue meant everyone who was available to help was supposed to report there immediately. 💔

Perspective. 

I was still in pain, nauseous, and missing my meeting. But at least I wasn't facing what those parents were facing. So I said a prayer for them and adjusted my attitude. My port started working, the nurse did her job, and I was on my way. 

A little reminder to keep things in perspective. 💜

#perspective #cancersucks #cancersurvior #farmersdaughterstrong #bekind
Seriously, there's no reason to worry about pestic Seriously, there's no reason to worry about pesticide residue on fresh produce. The EPA regulates the use of pesticides to make sure U.S. farmers use them safely. And the USDA takes annual samples to make sure what's on store shelves meets those safety standards. 

It's always recommended to wash produce before eating it though--because you never know who else touched it.

 Most importantly, eat and enjoy fresh fruit and vegetables! 🍐🍇🍌🥝🥦🫑🧅🍅

#agriculture #usagriculture #farmers #usfarmers #farming #farmfamilies #sustainableag #sustainableagriculture #sustainable #sustainability #farmerscare #homegrown #localagriculture #knowyourfarmer #shoplocal #madeintheusa #madeintheus #americanagriculture
Every kernel of corn, red tomato, and juicy peach Every kernel of corn, red tomato, and juicy peach that comes off our farm is part of us. 💜

#agriculture #usagriculture #farmers #usfarmers #farming #farmfamilies #sustainableag #sustainableagriculture #sustainable #sustainability #farmerscare #homegrown #localagriculture #knowyourfarmer #shoplocal #madeintheusa #madeintheus #americanagriculture
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2023 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs

Go to mobile version