The Farmer's Daughter USA

Hi, I'm Amanda! My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm also a practicing attorney.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Work with Me
    • Speaking
    • Giveaways
    • Social Media Consulting
    • Sponsored and Guest Posts
  • Gift Shop
    • Cart
    • Checkout
  • About Me
    • Media
    • Terms of Use

Cargill Proudly Partners with Non-GMO Project

March 22, 2017

Careful what you tweet…especially if you’re a company kicking your suppliers in the face. Right as National Agriculture Week was starting in the United States, the giant agriculture company Cargill tweeted this gem:

“We work closely with the #NonGMO Project & hope to have even more Cargill ingredients verified in the near future” https://t.co/HPwXEQAez7 pic.twitter.com/3rQrl7smMh

— Cargill (@Cargill) March 17, 2017

Cargill deals with food, agriculture, financial, and industrial products and services worldwide. Most farmers are probably familiar with the company, as we are, because we sell our corn and soybeans to their local granaries. Yes, that’s right, we sell our GMO grain products to Cargill who, in turn, sells that grain to its suppliers. Cargill buys a lot of GMO grain. In fact, they will only accept non-GMO grain at certain facilities and farmers have to contract at least a year in advanced. So, the non-GMO is definitely a specialty product, not the usual that Cargill deals in.

As part of its non-GMO product line, Cargill has what is called its KnownOrigins process. The process gives food manufacturers that purchase grains from the company the ability to buy non-GMO options. In turn, when those food manufacturers create their end products, they can claim that the product, including those ingredients from Cargill, are verified non-GMO. Cargill promises that the KnownOrigins process uses stringent standards, including testing, segregation, and traceability back to the farmer.

While I may not personally like the non-GMO product lines, I understand that Cargill has customers that want to purchase non-GMO products and Cargill wants to sell those products. Cargill is in the business of making money and I will not fault them for meeting a certain market demand. Cargill’s KnownOrigins program sounds completely adequate to keep track of and monitor where those non-GMO grains come from so they can assure buyers of the product’s integrity.

The problem is that they have partnered with the Non-GMO Project to obtain certification of products. Why?

The vast majority of people are probably familiar with the Non-GMO Project because they’ve seen it on products throughout their grocery stores. You know, the little orange butterfly with the words “Non-GMO Project Verified” on it. The program works because Non-GMO Project contracts with its founding member Global FoodChain Advisors to provide verification and testing of products. The costs of this verification are borne by the company seeking it (here, Cargill).

Unfortunately, while the organization might paint itself as an innocent verification process for non-GMO products, its roots go deep into the anti-GMO movement and its current activities are decidedly against the technology. As you can imagine there is plenty of the usual anti-GMO drivel coming out of the organization. It is pretty clear that the aim of the organization is to end the use of biotechnology entirely, which we have seen from many in the pro-labeling movement. First you stigmatize it, then you label it, then you stop using it.

In case you’re wondering, some of the major donors of the Non-GMO Project include the following: Annie’s Organic, Nature’s Path, Earth’s Best Organic, Eden Organic, Nutiva, Silk, Kashi, SunRidge Farms Organic, Traditional Medicinals Wellness Teas, and Dr. Bronner’s. Not that any of those folks have a financial interest in anti-GMO rhetoric or anything…

So, the question really comes down to – why the heck is Cargill paying this organization and supporting its efforts?!

Cargill has all but declared the Non-GMO Project the gold standard of non-GMO verification. In the article the company so proudly tweeted Lea Buerman, Cargill’s Food Safety, Quality, and Regulatory manager is quoted as saying: “Non-GMO Project Verification remains the most trusted emblem for consumers seeking non-GMO food options. We continue to work closely with the Non-GMO Project and hope to have even more Cargill ingredients verified in the near future.”

By praising the company, by partnering with them, by paying them money, by making them seem legitimate, Cargill is actively promoting anti-GMO propaganda. Non-GMO Project and its ilk liken GMO farmers to the devil spreading poisonous crops into the world, destroying the environment, and making people sick. That Cargill would endorse this message is a complete slap in the face to all the farmers that are growing GMO crops and contract for sale of those crops to Cargill.

Not surprisingly, Cargill got called out by quite a few people on Twitter. Cargill’s response has been one of the weakest I have literally ever seen from a company that got caught red-handed turning its back on farmers.

Really?! I suppose when you’ve done something as indefensible as this, then something as stupid as that is pretty much the only response you will be able to give. You actively work with this organization. You promote this organization. You financially support this organization. You praise this organization. You brag about your affiliation. …But you don’t support that organization’s agenda?

Isn’t that precisely the definition of endorsing an organization??

If Cargill wants to sell non-GMO product lines, then it can use its KnownOrigins process. But the affiliation with Non-GMO Project needs to end immediately, or maybe farmers need to start considering other options when selling their GMO grain.

Cargill, don’t bite the hand that feeds you.

signature

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Share this:
«
»

Filed Under: Biotechnology, Labeling, Marketing, Production Methods Tagged With: GMO, gmos

Comments

  1. Kathy Baumeister says

    March 23, 2017 at 10:51 am

    I thought that Cargill was a company based on science. How can they partner with an organization that uses fear to drive people away from technology that is proving to improve food & the environment? Cargill needs to rethink their position.

  2. Ann Niles says

    March 23, 2017 at 3:54 pm

    Has Cargill decided that farmers are not their customer base? I can’t imagine why any progressive farmer would want to do business with a business who thinks this is a good idea.

  3. Heather says

    March 23, 2017 at 5:40 pm

    Ugggh! How are we supposed to educate the general public when our agribusinesses contribute to the problem.

    I tend to stay away from organic, non, and natural lables. In my experience they are over priced, under appetizing and misleading. As a farmer I have a a firm grasp on where my food comes from. I trust my friends and neighbors. It’s disheartening to think that those who haven’t a clue, are able to manipulate marketing to such a degree.

  4. Kevin Folta says

    March 24, 2017 at 9:22 am

    If they want such a process they should spend the money and create their own. In fact, that’s a great idea. The NGP label has no offical sanction or verification. 90% of the stuff that is lableled doesn’t even have a GE equivalent. Time for an alternative, science-based label.

  5. Paulette says

    March 24, 2017 at 10:48 am

    Cargill could use better bean counters and PR people. Maybe someone with better judgement and the ability to resist temptation. Because even the best spin doctors would be hard-pressed to put a positive spin on such clumsy and craven avarice.

  6. Annie says

    March 25, 2017 at 8:42 pm

    Cargill customers required NonGM certification so Cargill worked with Project NonGMO to understand requirements etc. So basically it was to better understand what needed to happen to offer non GM products. Cargill isn’t endorsing what the org is promoting in any other way.

    • Amanda says

      March 25, 2017 at 10:27 pm

      I think the relationship goes much, much farther than just “understanding” what they needed. And Cargill is promoting the organization by allowing its names to be shown together, by “proudly” partnering with them, and by financially supporting them. You don’t get to work with an organization and then pretend that you don’t really like them or what they stand for. If that’s the case, then don’t partner with them.

Hi, I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney and I'm passionate about agriculture!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Subscribe via Email

Archives

Latest on Twitter

9 hours ago
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

40 Million American Jobs t.co/2VZm9fPWFt

  • Reply
  • Retweet 0
  • Like 0
1 day ago
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

Bee Careful: Walmart is Telling Farmers How to Farm t.co/SneuwrHrG2

  • Reply
  • Retweet 5
  • Like 9
April 12, 2021
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

Busting Myths on Organic Seeds t.co/Wr314ZZV5X

  • Reply
  • Retweet 1
  • Like 2

Latest on Facebook

The Farmer's Daughter

9 hours ago

The Farmer's Daughter

The recent Feeding the Economy report reveals that the US food and agriculture sectors are economic powerhouses! They represent 13 percent of all US jobs. These sectors contributed more than $2 trillion in wages in 2020. And nearly $797 billion in taxes. Food and agriculture contribute $7 trillion to the nation's economy. The report was commissioned by 33 food and ag groups. The numbers are staggering and, quite frankly, hard to conceptualize. But I share them for that very reason. Food and agriculture are huge. And these issues matter. It's worth taking the time to talk about them, (respectfully) debate them, and keep people engaged.

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

1 day ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Oh man. Here we go. Walmart is lecturing farmers about how to farm. Thanks, but we got this.

... See MoreSee Less

Bee Careful: Walmart is Telling Farmers How to Farm - The Farmer's Daughter USA

thefarmersdaughterusa.com

Walmart announced new requirements for its fresh produce suppliers to protect pollinators. Here's why I'm annoyed by it.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

4 days ago

The Farmer's Daughter

This week I'm continuing my review of organic-trade agreements. We're looking at the trade relationship between the US and Canada, and the big ways it differs from how we do business with Mexico. My latest for AGDAILY

... See MoreSee Less

Organic trade 101: The U.S.-Canada agreement | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

Aside from some differences between U.S. and Canada organic regulations, products accepted for certification in one country are accepted in the other.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

1 week ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Where are my gardeners? It seems like every year the garden space gets more and more entrenched in silly gimmicks like this. And I'm told social-media garden groups are the worst. So let's clear up some myths.🌱 Whether a seed is labeled organic or not depends on the parent plant. If the parent plant was only treated with organic pesticides (yes, those exist), the seeds can be labeled organic. If the parent plant is treated with conventional pesticides, it can't be labeled organic.🌱 It's worth mentioning that organic farmers don't always use "organic seed." If they can't find enough seed for their needs, they can use seeds from conventional parent plants and still label the plant and produce as organic.🌱 The seeds in these two packets are the same--same variety, same type of plant, same basil (literally the same picture too). You aren't getting anything extra for the organic seed, except the higher price tag.🌱 Using organic seeds doesn't result in better plants or more nutritious food. They also don't make the food you eat any safer or reduce exposure to chemicals.🌱 While we're talking about it, home gardeners usually don't have access to genetically modified varieties. So when you see the non-GMO label on a packet of seeds--especially ones of this size--that's a given. GMOs are generally only sold for commercial purposes in (very) large quantities. And some require the user to sign additional paperwork.#Seeds #GardenMythBusters

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Happy National Beer Day! 🍻Beer is agriculture! According to the National Beer Institute, barley is the most widely used grain in beer production. And farmers plant 3.5 million acres of barley each year to produce 190 million barrels of beer.

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

Latest on Instagram

thefarmersdaughterusa

I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney by day, and "agvocate" at night.

Amanda Zaluckyj
The recent Feeding the Economy report reveals that The recent Feeding the Economy report reveals that the US food and agriculture sectors are economic powerhouses! They represent 13 percent of all US jobs. These sectors contributed more than $2 trillion in wages in 2020. And nearly $797 billion in taxes. Food and agriculture contribute $7 trillion to the nation's economy. 

The report was commissioned by 33 food and ag groups. The numbers are staggering and, quite frankly, hard to conceptualize. But I share them for that very reason. Food and agriculture are huge. And these issues matter. It's worth taking the time to talk about them, (respectfully) debate them, and keep people engaged.

#agriculture #sustainableag #sustainability #farms #economicpowerhouse
Where are my gardeners? It seems like every year t Where are my gardeners? It seems like every year the garden space gets more and more entrenched in silly gimmicks like this. And I'm told social-media garden groups are the worst. So let's clear up some myths.

🌱 Whether a seed is labeled organic or not depends on the parent plant. If the parent plant was only treated with organic pesticides (yes, those exist), the seeds can be labeled organic. If the parent plant is treated with conventional pesticides, it can't be labeled organic.

🌱 It's worth mentioning that organic farmers don't always use "organic seed." If they can't find enough seed for their needs, they can use seeds from conventional parent plants and still label the plant and produce as organic.

🌱 The seeds in these two packets are the same--same variety, same type of plant, same basil (literally the same picture too). You aren't getting anything extra for the organic seed, except the higher price tag.

🌱 Using organic seeds doesn't result in better plants or more nutritious food. They also don't make the food you eat any safer or reduce exposure to chemicals.

🌱 While we're talking about it, home gardeners usually don't have access to genetically modified varieties. So when you see the non-GMO label on a packet of seeds--especially ones of this size--that's a given. GMOs are generally only sold for commercial purposes in (very) large quantities. And some require the user to sign additional paperwork.

#Seeds #GardenMythBusters #organicseeds
These are SO pretty this year! Hopefully no hard f These are SO pretty this year! Hopefully no hard freezes so they last awhile!

#myview #mygarden #rhodedendron
Well played, Mother Nature. Well played. #snow #a Well played, Mother Nature. Well played.

#snow #aprilfools #springiscoming🌸
I finally had the opportunity to safely visit the I finally had the opportunity to safely visit the dentist since 2019 (first it was the pandemic, then it was chemo). The receptionist greeted me as I entered the building. She was giving me total hair envy with her shoulder-length wavy, blonde hair. After checking me in she handed me some documents to sign and said, “your hair is so cute!”

“Oh, you think? I’m growing it out after chemo and I don’t really like it.” Well, it’s true. She responded by telling me that she really did mean it, but she understood because she remembered losing hers. After some conversation, I learned she went through chemo about seven years ago. She’s been cancer free since then. Now she looks just like anyone else; there was nothing about her that made me think “chemo” or “sick” or “cancer.”

Seven. Years. Now that sounds good.

When I first found out I had to go through chemo, I didn’t want to be part of “the club.” You know, the chemo club. The women who were all encouragement and survivors and little ribbons and slogans. I’m not sure if I was just being naive or in denial. I hoped I could put my head down, get through it, and put it in the rear-view mirror. Quickly. I didn’t really want to hang out and join “the club.” I just wanted to get beyond it.

But now I have a different perspective. The lady at the dentist’s office wasn’t just a slogan or a cheerleader. She was a symbol of hope. Seven years. And she understood something that most other people don’t. She knows how it feels to lose your hair and your identity and to not see yourself in the mirror anymore. She remembered how exhausting this is, even a few months later when I’m getting back to normal. She just…got it.

I still want to put cancer and chemo behind me. Forever. But now I’ll accept my membership card. Hopefully one day I’ll be that symbol of hope and kindness for someone else.

Also, I'm just so not feeling the hair. Sigh.

#cancersucks #cancer #FarmersDaughterStrong #bebrave
I love this bunny. He adds so much character to th I love this bunny. He adds so much character to the entryway.

#homedecor #homesweethome #springiscoming🌸
Happy National Ag Day! Today we officially celebr Happy National Ag Day!

Today we officially celebrate American agriculture. This year's theme is "Food brings everyone to the table." Every meal starts on the farm!

Food is such a personal thing. Each of us makes daily decisions about what we put in our body to nourish and fuel us. And because we're all making those choices, everyone has an opinion about it.

But those opinions should never detract from some important truths. We live in a time of abundance! We have the most widely available, consistent, safe, and nutritious food supply ever experienced in human history. While there are still those who go hungry, most of us suffer the opposite problem of having *too much* food.

So on National Ag Day let's appreciate that! Let's appreciate the bounty that comes from American farms and lands on our dinner tables. 

#NationalAgDay #NationalAgDay2021
I'm told EWG plans on releasing its annual "dirty I'm told EWG plans on releasing its annual "dirty dozen" list today. If you don't know, EWG ranks produce that has the highest levels of pesticide residue and suggests consumer purchase organic versions. 

But EWG and its list are nothing more than a dirty lie. Here's why:

🍎 The Environmental Protection Agency considers how pesticides can harm people before those pesticides are allowed for commercial use. And we know how much a person can encounter before they'll see any biological effect. That level is called a tolerance.

🥕 Tolerances are set extremely conservatively. Why? Because we want it to be completely unrealistic for any person to encounter enough pesticide residue to matter.

🥑 In fact, it would be *impossible* for you to eat enough pesticide residue to see an impact. For example, a woman could eat 850 apples IN ONE DAY and still not encounter enough pesticide residue to make a difference. You can calculate your own risk here: https://www.safefruitsandveggies.com/calculate/

🍑 We also make sure everyone is following the rules. USDA does annual, random sampling to make sure that the food in the grocery store is well within the tolerances. Each year, again and again, USDA's conclusion is that there's nothing to worry about. Read about the latest results here: https://thefarmersdaughterusa.com/usda-another-year-with-no-concerning-levels-of-pesticide-residue/

🥦 If you're still concerned about pesticide residue, wash your produce for 20 seconds under running water. That will clean it right up! Quite frankly, you should probably do this anyway because you never know who touched your food along the supply chain!

🍇 The only thing you should be worried about when it comes to fruits and vegetables is whether you're eating enough of them! Most of us aren't! So stop paying attention to labels and start eating!
Dose 1 of 2. ✔ #covid19 #covid_19 #vaccine #ᴠ Dose 1 of 2. ✔

#covid19 #covid_19 #vaccine #ᴠᴀᴄᴄɪɴᴇssᴀᴠᴇʟɪᴠᴇs #vaccinate #covidvacccine
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2021 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs