The Farmer's Daughter USA

Hi, I'm Amanda! My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm also a practicing attorney.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Work with Me
    • Speaking
    • Giveaways
    • Social Media Consulting
    • Sponsored and Guest Posts
  • About Me
    • Media
    • Terms of Use

Lawsuit Challenging Vermont Labeling Law Fired – Not the First Time!

June 30, 2014

As I reported back in April, Vermont’s legislature and governor signed into law a bill that requires all As predicted, some industry groups, including the Grocery Manufacturer’s Association, the Snack Food Association, the International Dairy Foods Association and the National Association of Manufacturers, have filed suit against the state asking the courts to issue an injunction from the law being enforced.

Vermont manufacturers to label any items that contain genetically modified crops.

The lawsuit argues that the labeling law is unconstitutional and cites various authorities, including the FDA, which have concluded that GMOs are perfectly safe. They’re also challenging the use of a third-party fund which the state will use to defend the law. (Ben & Jerry’s pledged to help raise money for the fund.)

But this isn’t the first time Vermont has been in this position. That’s right: they’ve been sued before on mandatory labeling measures.

The best part? Vermont lost.

In the case of International Dairy Foods Associate MIF v. Amestoy, the Plaintiffs filed the lawsuit for temporary injunctive relief to prevent Vermont from enforcing a mandatory labeling of dairy products from cows given a growth hormone, rBST. In the case, the Supreme Court of Vermont held for the Plaintiffs, because it stated the law violated the industry’s free speech rights. Important to the court was the fact that the FDA has approved the hormone for safe use and that the end product was indistinguishable from similar products made without the hormone.

Sound familiar?

Just as in Amestoy, the FDA has found that biotechnology is completely safe and also that GMO products are indistinguishable from non-GMO products.

First, the Plaintiffs had to show that they had been dealt in “irreparable harm” from the law. On that point the Court held:

We need not resolve this controversy at this point;  even assuming that the compelled disclosure is purely commercial speech, appellants have amply demonstrated that the First Amendment is sufficiently implicated to cause irreparable harm. . . The dairy manufacturers have clearly done more than simply “assert” their First Amendment rights:  The statute in question indisputably requires them to speak when they would rather not.

You can imagine a similar argument by the groups bringing suit against the GMO labeling law. They are being forced to speak on production methods when they have no real incentive to do so.

The harder hurdle for those challenging the law may be a second test which, in part, requires the state to prove it has a “substantial interest” in enforcing the law. In Amestoy, Vermont had no claimed that health or safety concerns prompted the law. Instead, Vermont indicated that the statute was passed on the basis of “stronger consumer interest and the public’s ‘right to know.'”

In this case, there isn’t any scientific data to support an argument that GMOs are harmful to humans or the environment. However, how much “proof” is needed may be the problem.

There are also several different avenues the industry groups could take to overturn the law, including using the Commerce Clause and federal law pre-emption. I will definitely continue to follow this case, because it is certainly a fascinating one. Hopefully, common sense and science can rue the day.

signature
Share this:
«
»

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, GMO, labels, legal

Comments

  1. jan says

    June 30, 2014 at 7:05 pm

    Thanks for following this case. Amazing when lawmakers know more than anyone else about what is safe for consumptionl

Hi, I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney and I'm passionate about agriculture!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Subscribe via Email

Archives

Latest on Facebook

The Farmer's Daughter

4 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

You can't and won't make America healthy by blaming and hindering our family farmers.

... See MoreSee Less

MAHA Report delivers scathing assessment of farm pesticides | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

The new MAHA report, led by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., links pesticides to rising childhood illness, already drawing criticism from farm groups.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

1 month ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Do you a plan for your estate? My latest for AGDAILY focuses on potential changes to the federal estate tax.

... See MoreSee Less

Perspective: A farmer's legacy shouldn't be a tax nightmare for their kin

www.agdaily.com

For farm families, estate taxes aren’t just an abstract policy debate -- they’re a very real threat to generational farms and the livelihoods they support.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

1 month ago

The Farmer's Daughter

If nothing else, this should keep you up at night. Every snake oil salesman is now in charge of HHS.

... See MoreSee Less

How RFK Jr. Is Boosting ‘Food Babe’ and Other MAHA Acolytes

www.wsj.com

The health and human services secretary has elevated lightly regulated wellness companies and allowed advisers to keep investments, after vowing to end conflicts of interest.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 months ago

The Farmer's Daughter

These concepts aren't mutually exclusive.

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 months ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Imagine getting to donate a substantial amount of money to a charity of *your* choice and you choose....an animal rights activist group with questionable intentions??

... See MoreSee Less

Why agricultural advocates are lashing out at Celebrity Jeopardy! | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

David Friedberg, founder of The Climate Corporation, is drawing ire for his "charity" of choice on Celebrity Jeopardy!: Humane World for Animals.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

Latest on Instagram

Amanda Zaluckyj

thefarmersdaughterusa

Amanda | The Farmer's Daughter USA
I'm a proud farmer's daughter & advocate for modern agriculture. U.S. farmers are leaders in sustainability.

Perusing my photos from #Denmark and getting the i Perusing my photos from #Denmark and getting the itch to travel again.
These concepts aren't mutually exclusive. #farms # These concepts aren't mutually exclusive. #farms #farmfamily #environment #soilhealth #nutritiousfood
Stop worrying about labels and just eat them! Stop worrying about labels and just eat them!
Corn is a powerhouse! #corn #farming #growcorn # Corn is a powerhouse! 

#corn #farming #growcorn #USAGrown #usagriculture
Happy St. Patrick's Day! 🍀 Happy St. Patrick's Day! 🍀
The blood moon. 🌙 And proof I woke up at 2:15 a The blood moon. 🌙 And proof I woke up at 2:15 am to see it!
3 years. 💔 #slavaukraini #supporukraine #ukrai 3 years. 💔

#slavaukraini #supporukraine #ukraine #glorytoukraine🇺🇦
Mischa will not suffer a snowman in her yard. ❄️☃️

#dogslife #dogsofinstagram #blacklab #pittiemix #snowday #snowman
We all know RFK, Jr. is well known for vaccine dis We all know RFK, Jr. is well known for vaccine disinformation. But he's also a danger to agriculture, even promising to "weaponize" regulatory agencies against our farm families.

#rfk #farmersdaughter #farmers #conspiracytheories #puremichiganfarm #rfkjr
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2025 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs