The Farmer's Daughter USA

Hi, I'm Amanda! My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm also a practicing attorney.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Work with Me
    • Speaking
    • Giveaways
    • Social Media Consulting
    • Sponsored and Guest Posts
  • Gift Shop
    • Cart
    • Checkout
  • About Me
    • Media
    • Terms of Use

Federal Judge Kicks GMO Ban in Hawaii

July 6, 2015

Hawaii is now free and clear of any and all GMO cultivation bans! While that’s certainly a reason to celebrate for the islands’ farmers, the decision actually has potential for supporting farmers throughout the country.

Last November, voters in Maui County, Hawaii passed a ballot proposal that banned the production of genetically modified crops within the county. During the same election, voters in Kaui County and Hawaii County also passed similar measures. As I reported previously, another federal judge in Hawaii ruled that the Kauai County ban was preempted by state law and blocked enforcement of the ban. That same judge also concluded the Hawaii County ballot initiative was preempted by state and (partially) federal law.

Late last week, federal Judge Susan Oki Mollway similarly overturned the ban in Maui County, holding  that the Hawaii County law was preempted by state and federal law. Specifically, the federal Plant Protection Act (PPA) and a state law regarding unwanted plants. Therefore, the law could not be enforced and the ban was struck down.

Also, unique and interesting to this particular ban, is the fact that Monsanto and Dow Chemical actually have research farms in Maui County. Obviously, the warm weather allows the companies to do significant research year round. While this didn’t influence the court’s decision, it makes the victory a little sweeter.

So, how is this potentially good for all farmers? Let me explain…

Preemption

First, let’s explore what it means that a law has been “preempted.” As you’re probably aware, the United States has a hierarchy of laws – the Constitution trumps federal laws, which trump state laws, which trumps local laws. In other words, laws created and implemented farther down the chain cannot be in direct contrast to laws that are higher on the chain. For example, if the Constitution makes X legal, a federal law making X illegal would be unenforceable. Likewise, if a state law also tried to make X illegal, it would be unenforceable.

The laws of preemption are a bit more complicated than that, but essentially, if a law enacted by a governing body lower on the chain is in direct contrast with a law passed by a body higher on the chain, it is preempted and should be struck down.

This was essentially the conclusion Judge Molloway reached regarding the Maui County ban. The Maui County law ran contrary to the PPA and, therefore was not enforceable. Worth noting, the Hawaii County ban was partially overturned by Judge Kurren for being preempted by federal law.

The Plant Protection Act

Briefly, let’s look at how Judge Mollway reached this conclusion. Sometimes federal law will contain a preemption clause when applicable. That is, the law itself will clearly state that it trumps any lower level laws. (That’s because if the law doesn’t include a preemption clause, there can sometimes be a question of whether the legal doctrine applies. Since I’m trying to make this simple, that other analysis isn’t so important.) It’s a nice way of Congress explicitly telling the judicial branch if preemption should apply.

As explained by JD Supra, the PPA contains a preemption clause and Judge Mollway clearly concluded that it applied to the county ordinance.

As reported by the KauaiEclectic, Judge Mollway’s opinion stated:

The statute prohibits the County from regulating the movement (including the release into the environment) of GE organisms in interstate commerce, if they are plant pests or noxious weeds. The Plant Protection Act includes the express statement that “all plant pests, noxious weeds, plants, plant products, articles capable of harboring plant pests or noxious weeds regulated under [the Plant Protection Act] are in or affect interstate commerce or foreign commerce.”

To determine whether preemption applies, this court must examine whether GE organisms can be considered either plant pests or noxious weeds. This court need not look beyond the language in the Ordinance itself in this regard. [T]he Ordinance inherently considers GE organisms to be “noxious weeds” and/or “plant pests.”

Pursuant to the PPA, if the Secretary of Agriculture has issued a regulation that prevents the dissemination of a pest or noxious weed, then any state or local law that also tries to regulate a plant in order to control a pest or noxious weed is preempted. See 7 U.S.C. § 7756(b). The Secretary of Agriculture has already issued regulations that govern genetically engineered crops. Remember, the federal government only de-regulates a new GMO plant for commercial use once its been reviewed by (at least) the USDA and EPA, and sometimes the FDA.  Therefore, because the Maui County law banned GMO plants, defining them as “noxious weeds” and “plant pests,” which are explicitly regulated by the PPA, Judge Mollway found the county law was preempted by those regulations.

Literally, the ordinance defeated itself.

Going Beyond Hawaii

So you might be thinking, so what? Hawaii certainly seems to have a more radical fringe voting block that allowed for the passage for 3 different cultivation bans in the state. Aside from Oregon, Hawaii is the craziest state out there.

But these judicial opinions, which determined the bans were preempted by federal legislation, could have precedential effect in other parts of the country. See, courts are supposed to look at how other courts have handled similar issues when deciding how to rule on a case. These two decisions should weigh on any federal court that hears a case like this, even if the court is in a different jurisdiction and, ultimately, decides the case differently. That means that if another county in a different state passes a similar law, a federal judge could rely on these opinions to make a decision.

Even more interesting, one of the individuals that helped sponsor the ballot initiative in Maui County has publicly indicated he will appeal this decision. That means a federal court of appeals could make a ruling on this case – perhaps the first one like it in the country. If the court affirmed the decision, that would result in a federal precedent holding that county-level GMO bans are not enforceable throughout that jurisdiction. Of course, the opposite could happen as well.

Either way, these decisions could have country-wide application. If other counties in the country attempt to pass similar bans, these decisions will probably influence how those bans are written. We’ll have to wait a little bit to see how far this goes, but it doesn’t take much imagination to think that there could be circuit splits, especially considering the Oregon cases, and this issue may be taken all the way to the Supreme Court.

Of course, that’s jumping the gun a little bit, but I find the possibility a bit thrilling and nerve wracking.

In the meantime, congratulations to Maui County, Hawaii for getting the GMO cultivation ban overturned! I love hearing this type of good news!

(If you would like to keep up on everything happening with agriculture in Hawaii, be sure to check out The Hawaii’s Farmer’s Daughter!)

signature
Share this:
«
»

Filed Under: Bans, Biotechnology Tagged With: ballot measures, gmos, Hawaii, legal

Comments

  1. Mark says

    July 8, 2015 at 2:51 pm

    Thanks for the more thorough explanation of the judge’s ruling than I have been able to find elsewhere. It is disappointing that the ruling is so limited – ie that the judge didn’t rule counties couldn’t regulate GMOs, just that counties couldn’t regulate GMOs because they are pests. This seems to leave the door open to regulate GMOs ‘just because’, and it seems likely that this will lead to another round of divisive county initiative processes.

Hi, I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney and I'm passionate about agriculture!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Subscribe via Email

Archives

Latest on Twitter

May 1, 2023
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

Healthy Soil’s Big Impact t.co/xBO5tCKP17

  • Reply
  • Retweet 0
  • Like 2
March 29, 2023
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

The Silver Lining in This Year’s Dirty Dozen List t.co/qD3kFSYmtE

  • Reply
  • Retweet 0
  • Like 1
March 2, 2023
Farmers Daughter's Twitter avatar
Farmers Daughter
@farmdaughterusa

Right-to-Repair Challenges Continue t.co/sOTL8t7fPx

  • Reply
  • Retweet 3
  • Like 4

Latest on Facebook

The Farmer's Daughter

3 hours ago

The Farmer's Daughter

We won't finish #plant23 today. But we'll be really, really close. So what happens then? My latest on AGDAILY

... See MoreSee Less

6 ways crop farmers stay busy throughout the summer | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

Crop farmers have plenty to keep them busy during the summer months, though it's true that they may not be working every single day.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

3 days ago

The Farmer's Daughter

The floor is lava. Except now we're adults and it's actually poison ivy. 😂

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

1 week ago

The Farmer's Daughter

We're done planting corn!! 🥳🥳 I haven't posted many updates about #plant23 because it's been a little rough. 🫣 But we're getting there!

... See MoreSee Less


Photo

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

And...go!

... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

The Farmer's Daughter

2 weeks ago

The Farmer's Daughter

Reducing food waste is a goal we should all have. Vilifying a product that can help us do that with disinformation isn't helping. My latest for AGDAILY

... See MoreSee Less

Social media is wrong to vilify Apeel's shelf-life technique | AGDAILY

www.agdaily.com

Apeel is a useful tool to safely and effectively extend the shelf life of fresh produce, yet activists aim to denigrate this remedy to food waste.

View on Facebook

·
Share



Share on Facebook



Share on Twitter



Share on Linked In



Share by Email

Latest on Instagram

thefarmersdaughterusa

I'm Amanda. My family farms corn and soybeans in Southwest Michigan. I'm an attorney by day, and "agvocate" at night.

Amanda Zaluckyj
The floor is lava. Except now we're adults ans it' The floor is lava. Except now we're adults ans it's actually poison ivy. 😂😂

#floorislava #poisonivy
Consumers are feeling the pinch, and so are farmer Consumers are feeling the pinch, and so are farmers. The increased costs for #plant23 stem from higher seed, fertilizer, chemical, and land costs. Farmers are also paying higher interest rates. And keep in mind that #plant22 was also more costly than pre-COVID times.

#agriculture #hardtimes #plant23 #plant2023 #sustainableag #economicsustainabilty #usagriculture #usfarms #usfarmers
I don't know who needs this today, but here's Misc I don't know who needs this today, but here's Mischa with the sadest puppy-dog eyes and adorable belly rolls. 😍😍

#Mischa #dogsofinstagram #dogs #bellyrubs
Food labeling matters. Here's why. #food #foodlab Food labeling matters. Here's why.

#food #foodlabels #foodlabelsmatter #knowyourfarmer #knowyourfood
Just in case you're not sure why I miss my straigh Just in case you're not sure why I miss my straight hair. It randomly failed to curl last week. This was the beautiful result. 😍

#cancersurvivor #chemocurls #farmersdaughterstrong #bebrave
Don't let anyone tell you that farmers (yes, even Don't let anyone tell you that farmers (yes, even conventional farmers) don't care about soil health. The truth is, farmers are *obsessed* with it.

#farming #agriculture #healthysoil #soilhealth #sustainableag #sustainableagriculture #modernagriculture #modernag
Modern planting is a lot more sophisticated than j Modern planting is a lot more sophisticated than just placing seeds in the ground. Our equipment actually allows us to control how many plants we want per acre, precisely spaces each corn seed in the rows, and controls how deep the seed is planted. It's all part of precision agriculture that employs high-tech sensors and data to improve efficiency and yields.

#farming #modernagriculture #corn #cornplanting #plant23 #plant2023 #plant #farms #sustainable #sustainableagriclture #themoreyouknow💫 #usagriculture
Perspective. Last week I was in the cancer center Perspective.

Last week I was in the cancer center for routine labs and a port flush. Unfortunately, my port wasn't working. There's al these little "tricks" the nurse tries to open it up. One of those was putting different pressure on it. Needless to say, it hurt! And it didn't work. So she had to get something called TPA, put it in the line, and let it work--something that takes at least a half hour.

So there I sat for half an hour. In pain. A bit nauseous. And missing a work meeting. As you can imagine, I wasn't super happy about any of it.

But then came a voice over the hospital's intercom system (something that NEVER happens). There was a Code Blue in the neo-natal center. I asked my nurse what that meant. She said a baby was born without breathing. The doctors would do everything they could to resuscitate, and the Code Blue meant everyone who was available to help was supposed to report there immediately. 💔

Perspective. 

I was still in pain, nauseous, and missing my meeting. But at least I wasn't facing what those parents were facing. So I said a prayer for them and adjusted my attitude. My port started working, the nurse did her job, and I was on my way. 

A little reminder to keep things in perspective. 💜

#perspective #cancersucks #cancersurvior #farmersdaughterstrong #bekind
Seriously, there's no reason to worry about pestic Seriously, there's no reason to worry about pesticide residue on fresh produce. The EPA regulates the use of pesticides to make sure U.S. farmers use them safely. And the USDA takes annual samples to make sure what's on store shelves meets those safety standards. 

It's always recommended to wash produce before eating it though--because you never know who else touched it.

 Most importantly, eat and enjoy fresh fruit and vegetables! 🍐🍇🍌🥝🥦🫑🧅🍅

#agriculture #usagriculture #farmers #usfarmers #farming #farmfamilies #sustainableag #sustainableagriculture #sustainable #sustainability #farmerscare #homegrown #localagriculture #knowyourfarmer #shoplocal #madeintheusa #madeintheus #americanagriculture
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2023 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs

Go to mobile version